Drawing on conversations with Rehana Ramesh, director ICT, Digital and Customer Services at Hackney Council, Diana Rebaza, senior research analyst with Socitm, explores how a Data Ethics Board can support innovation, manage risk and strengthen public trust.
Hackney’s experience offers you a practical way to embed data ethics across your organisation. Helping you to build trust and make responsible (and ethical) evidence-based decisions.
Local government has always used data and information to make decisions.
But the quantity of data you have access to now is vast.
Using any of it will directly affect residents’ service experiences and their trust in you.
Data helps councils like yours better understand residents and make evidence-based decisions to improve outcomes for people and communities.
But good intentions and better technology are not enough when working with data.
You need to consider: who’s using it; how they are using it and whether they are allowed to use it the way that they’re using it.
If you’re using data to design a process or to make a decision, how do any of us know that you’re doing that in an ethical way?
At Hackney, they’re dealing with this as a governance issue instead of a persistent theoretical debate that never really gets resolved one way or another.
Why and how did Hackney create a data ethics board?
Data effects everybody in your council.
When you have thousands of staff, you’re all using it in your day-to-day work; inputting and interpreting data on behalf of residents, members, colleagues, senior leadership.
It’s everyone. So, everyone needs to have a good understanding of what data is and how to use it.
Hackney was able to build on existing knowledge, sector learning and senior commitment. No wheel was reinvented and no-one faced a blank page.
They invested in a data platform, but also in the skills, governance and insight needed to make effective use of it.
After benchmarking with organisations and colleagues experienced with ethics boards, they chose the Open Data Institute’s (ODI) data ethics canvas framework because of its simplicity.
The ODI described their canvas as: “…a tool for anyone who collects, shares or uses data. It helps identify and manage ethical issues – at the start of a project that uses data, and throughout. It encourages you to ask important questions about projects that use data and reflect on the responses.
“These might be: What is your primary purpose for using data in this project?
"Who could be negatively affected by this project?
“The Data Ethics Canvas provides a framework to develop ethical guidance that suits any context, whatever the project’s size or scope.”
Rehana described it as: simple and practical; trialled through a 3-month pilot; supported by ODI-led training; structured around 16 questions; strong on identifying negative impacts, positive impacts, mitigation actions, and communication responsibilities; and used as a standard assessment process for data projects before they reach the advisory board. By asking project teams to work through a common framework before coming to the board, Hackney has created a consistent way to surface the issues that matter most.
Who’s on the data ethics board?
It’s chaired by Hackney chief executive Dawn Carter-McDonald and co-chaired with Rehana.
Membership includes legal, information governance and key senior service representation, alongside perspectives from academia, the NHS, and local government partners (including Socitm).
Hackney also trained their board members through the ODI, rather than assuming that they know what data ethics is. It also keeps a register of recommendations so advice can be acted on and reviewed.
The board is advisory rather than decision-making.
How does it really work?
A couple of anonymised examples.
Debt
A dashboard shows one household owing £15,000 and another £2,000. While it seems obvious to target the bigger debt, what’s going on underneath those numbers. The smaller debt might be masking a family in more trouble because they’re not putting their heating on or eating just two meals because they want to pay their debt.
The numbers are accurate, but the ethical question is whether it’s showing the whole picture.
Who’s on the data ethics board?
It’s chaired by Hackney chief executive Dawn Carter-McDonald and co-chaired with Rehana.
Membership includes legal, information governance and key senior service representation, alongside perspectives from academia, the NHS, and local government partners (including Socitm).
Hackney also trained their board members through the ODI, rather than assuming that they know what data ethics is. It also keeps a register of recommendations so advice can be acted on and reviewed.
The board is advisory rather than decision-making.
How does it really work?
A couple of anonymised examples.
Debt
A dashboard shows one household owing £15,000 and another £2,000. While it seems obvious to target the bigger debt, what’s going on underneath those numbers. The smaller debt might be masking a family in more trouble because they’re not putting their heating on or eating just two meals because they want to pay their debt.
The numbers are accurate, but the ethical question is whether it’s showing the whole picture.
Your 6 lessons for creating (and evaluating) a data ethics board
Don’t reinvent the wheel: use existing frameworks and tools to move more quickly.
Testing: Hackney uses pilots to better understand what works in the real world.
Training: Rehana’s ambition is for data ethics to become mandatory training.
Secure senior sponsorship: a board backed by senior leadership is more likely to be taken seriously.
Keep the board advisory so it enables delivery rather than slowing it down.
Share what you’re doing with colleagues across the sector.
About Hackney Council
Hackney is home to around 267,000 residents and one of the UK’s most diverse and densely populated urban areas. Alongside this diversity, Hackney faces significant social and economic challenges.
About Socitm
The Society for Innovation, Technology, and Modernisation is a membership charity for people working in UK local public services. We support members with our philosophy to simplify, standardise, share and sustain best practice wherever we find it. Bringing what works into members’ teams, places and communities.
Socitm is the only UK member of LOLA, the Organisation of Local Authority ICT Societies. LOLA includes organisations from Australia, Belgium, Canada, The Netherlands, New Zealand, Sweden, UK and USA.
ODI Data Ethics Canvas
ODI Data Ethics Canvas interactive tool